10 Home Renovation Projects That No Longer Pay Off – Think Twice Before You Remodel

January 16, 2024

Home Renovation Project

If you’re thinking of renovating your home, you might want to reconsider. Some of the most popular home improvement projects are not worth the investment anymore.

Here are ten home renovation projects that no longer pay off, and what you can do instead.

1. Adding A Sunroom


Sunrooms used to be a desirable feature for home buyers, but not anymore. According to Remodeling Magazine, the average cost of adding a sunroom is $75,000, but the return on investment is only 51%. That means you’ll lose almost half of your money if you sell your home.

Instead of adding a sunroom, consider improving your outdoor space with a deck, patio, or pergola. These projects are cheaper and can increase your home’s value by up to 72%.

2. Installing A Swimming Pool

Swimming Pool

Swimming pools may seem like a fun and luxurious addition to your home, but they can also be a hassle and a liability. Pools require regular maintenance, insurance, and safety measures, which can add up to thousands of dollars per year. Plus, many buyers see pools as a turn-off, especially in colder climates.

Instead of installing a swimming pool, invest in landscaping and outdoor lighting. These projects can enhance your curb appeal and make your backyard more inviting and enjoyable.

3. Converting Your Garage

Garage Conversion

Garages are not just for parking cars anymore. Many homeowners convert their garages into living spaces, such as bedrooms, offices, or gyms. However, this can backfire when it comes to selling your home. Buyers value having a garage for storage and security, and may not appreciate your customizations.

A better solution is organizing and upgrading it. You can add shelving, cabinets, flooring, and lighting to make your garage more functional and attractive.

4. Replacing Your Windows

Window replacement


Replacing your windows may seem like a smart way to save energy and money, but it’s not as cost-effective as you might think. The average cost of replacing windows is $19,000, but the return on investment is only 69%. It can take decades to recoup the cost through energy savings.

To save money on your windows, improve their efficiency with caulking, weatherstripping, and window treatments. These are cheaper and easier ways to reduce drafts and heat loss.

5. Remodeling Your Bathroom

Bathroom Remodel

Bathroom remodels are one of the most common home improvement projects, but they can also be one of the most expensive. The average cost of remodeling a bathroom is $21,000, but the return on investment is only 64%. That means you’ll only get back two-thirds of what you spent.

An option when remodeling your bathroom is to refresh it with minor updates. You can paint the walls, replace the fixtures, install new lighting, and add accessories to give your bathroom a new look without breaking the bank.

6. Adding A Main Suite

Main Suite


Main suites are another popular home improvement project that can cost a lot of money and time. The average cost of adding a master suite is $136,000, but the return on investment is only 58%. That means you’ll lose over 40% of your money if you sell your home.

Improve your existing bedroom with some simple changes. You can paint the walls, add some furniture, hang some artwork, and buy some new bedding to create a cozy and comfortable retreat.

7. Finishing Your Basement

finished basement

Basements are often overlooked spaces that can be transformed into extra living areas. However, finishing your basement can be a costly and complicated project that may not pay off in the end. The average cost of finishing a basement is $71,000, but the return on investment is only 53%. That means you’ll lose almost half of your money if you sell your home.

Make your basement more usable and appealing with some basic improvements. You can clean it up, paint the walls, install some flooring, and add some lighting to make it more inviting and functional.

8. Over-the-Top Landscaping

over the top landscaping

High-end landscaping with elaborate designs and exotic plants may seem appealing, but it can be extremely costly and may not significantly increase the value of your home. Potential buyers might view such landscaping as high maintenance or overly personalized.

It’s best to focus on basic lawn care, neat flower beds, and simple, clean designs that appeal to a broader range of people. These changes can improve curb appeal without breaking the bank.

9. Luxury Kitchen Overhaul

Luxury Kitchen

While kitchen updates can be a good investment, going overboard with luxury materials and high-end appliances may not yield the best return. Ultra-luxurious kitchen remodels can cost a fortune and may only appeal to a specific buyer niche.

What you should consider are modest upgrades like repainting cabinets, updating hardware, and replacing outdated appliances with mid-range models. These changes can refresh the kitchen’s look without a hefty investment.

10. Expanding Living Space with an Addition

room addition

Adding extra rooms or significantly expanding the living space can be a risky investment. Such projects are often expensive and may not appeal to all buyers, especially if the addition disrupts the flow or character of the home. Additionally, larger homes can incur higher property taxes and utility costs.

A more cost-effective alternative is to optimize existing space through reorganization or light remodeling, such as turning an unused attic or den into a functional room.

Home Renovations Can Be Tempting

Home Renovations

Home renovation projects can be tempting ways to improve your living space and increase your home’s value. However, not all projects are worth the investment. Before you start any home improvement project, do some research and compare the costs and benefits. You might find that there are better ways to spend your money and time.

What home renovation projects have you done? Did they pay off when you sold your home? Let us know in the comments below.

Read More:

7 Things That Should Be Replaced in Your Home Every Decade

4 Things to Consider Before Installing a Skylight in Your Home

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *