Replacement Society: Save Money By Keeping Things Longer


The sounds coming from our eighteen year old refrigerator have recently changed. There’s more moaning and banging now instead of the smooth hum that has always been there. I’ve taken this as the cue to begin the search for a replacement, after attempting to solve the problem myself. The search has been depressing in more ways than one. I’ve had trouble finding anything that I like and, even worse, anything that seems remotely reliable. My search took me to the local appliance place. I was hoping for more advice and knowledge than I’d gotten at the big box stores.

Anyway, when we got there we got a very friendly salesman who, for once, wasn’t super pushy. In making conversation we mentioned how old the fridge is and that led to a conversation about how old some of our other appliances are (they’re all the same age since they came new with the house). I told him how all these new bells and whistles on refrigerators just weren’t my thing (a TV in the fridge? Really?) and how I preferred to keep things simple. Jokingly I mentioned that we’d only gotten a flat screen TV this year when our tube TV finally died. The salesman then started talking about his recent search for a new car (to replace his “ancient” four year old car) and when I mentioned that my car is closing in on sixteen years old, he exclaimed, “Wow. You really are living in the dark ages!”

This isn’t the first time I’ve heard this or something similar to it. People seem to think it’s fun to make jokes about how old our cars are, or to comment on our lack of smart phones and tablets, or to joke about how close we are to being Luddites. (Really, we’re not that close.) We’re not living in the dark ages because we’re afraid of technology. Instead, we’re well aware that all of this technology comes with a hefty price tag.

Every time you buy/upgrade a car, computer, washer, cell phone, dryer or other appliance, that’s cash you don’t have for other things. Sure, sometimes you have no choice. Things break down and have to be replaced. But what I call “recreational replacement/acquisition” (which is buying when there’s not a real need, simply a desire for something newer) is costly. Unless you have a very high income, that’s the sort of behavior that will land you in financial trouble, eventually. Look at an example:

  • I’ve kept my fridge for 18 years. I’ve banked money in my “emergency fund” for this moment all those years. I easily have the $1,200 to $1,800 to get the model that I want. I’ll pay that money once and hopefully not again for at least another ten years (I’d love it if I could go longer, but I’m not encouraged by the reviews I’m seeing. They don’t make ’em like they used to.)
  • Had I upgraded it every five years, instead, I would have paid (let’s just say) $1,500 every five years. Over eighteen years, that’s $5,400. And that’s just one appliance. Do it for a whole kitchen and it’s a lot more money.

It’s the same with cell phones. Stick with one for five years and you’ve only paid (we’ll say that you pay on your own and it’s not part of your contract, etc.) $300. If you upgrade every six months, you’ve paid $3,000 over those five years. Even if you upgrade once per year that’s still $1,500. Computers, tablets, cars, video game systems and anything else that has an “upgrade appeal” can break you if you insist on always having something newer. This is especially true if you’re caught in the upgrade cycle for everything you own. The costs of keeping a “newer” car, phone, computer, appliance, and TV can quickly add up to scary amounts of money.

On the other hand, if you live in the dark ages like me and only replace something when it truly needs replacing (or when you buy something because you’ve identified a concrete need or benefit that it will add to your life), you will save a ton of money. My old car still runs very well. Working from home I use it lightly so it will probably last me many more years. My appliances do their job. My phone makes calls. As long as things do what I need them to do, I don’t feel a need to add lots of upgrades to them every time a new feature becomes available. Instead I choose to bank that money, invest it wisely, and spend it on things that give me much more value than a TV in my refrigerator.

(Photo courtesy of kevin dooley)

This entry was posted in Frugal, Personal Finance, Saving Money, Shopping and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Replacement Society: Save Money By Keeping Things Longer

  1. jay says:

    Fighting the good fight against planned obsolescence!

    Saving for those big ticket items is getting more and more difficult, though: how long do you have, how much will “it” cost, etc.

  2. Diane says:

    I agree! I keep most things until they break & need repairs that are not worth making, within reason. It is true that appliances do not last as long as they used to! Computers we’ve installed new hard drives, but eventually they need replacement.

    I do upgrade my cell phone every 2 years, which is not that much with a contract, depending on the phone of course. If you run into problems & need a phone replaced under contract, it gets difficult as they get older, because they give you refurbished phones in your model that don’t really work. I’m having that problem now with my phone. When the contract renews in January I’ll get a new model.

    It is easier to keep an older car if you don’t have to use it every day & there’s another car in the household. When I was a single parent driving an older car many miles a week to work & kids’ schools/activities that was tough, as it was the only car we had. My 2006 van was in the shop this week for repairs & I was able to use by boyfriend’s car when needed, as we both work from home~ makes life much easier. I’ll keep this car until the repairs start costing too much.

  3. Karen says:

    There are some benefits though of upgrading. When my 10 year old fridge crapped out and we got a new one, our electricity bill went down $20 a month. That’s $240 a year so it will pay itself back in ten years, if it lasts that long.


  4. Kevin Mzansi says:

    Must say I prefer to stay in the dark ages if it saves me a bunch of money!

  5. Richard says:

    We had a car lease (Ill never lease again) that expired and returned the vehicle. Bought a 2001 Honda which came with a new set of snow tires for really cheap. Ive saved the old lease payment amounts in the bank sinced and have saved over $5000.00 in what would have been car payments…..and the bonus, other than two oil changes and gas, we have spent nothing extra on the honda….

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *