Taxes Have Political Correctness Issues

taxes and political correctness

In the spirit of political correctness, the IRS long ago did away with the old designations of “husband” and “wife” on individual tax returns, and replaced them with “taxpayer” and “spouse.” The result of this change has led to many headaches for tax practitioners.

It seems that every tax season, inevitably one client will come in to my office and the wife will have it in her craw that she shall be reported as the “taxpayer”; her husband should be “spouse.” Sometimes this demand comes with a reason, something like, “I made more money this year so I am the taxpayer.” Or often the wife (or spouse) is just upset about the unfairness of her husband hogging up that top line. The form was changed to be politically correct, so why not take advantage?

Unfortunately, try as they might, the IRS is not set up to allow married women to start taking the top line as “taxpayer.” The IRS Form 1040 instructions read, “if you filed a joint return for 2005 and you are filing a joint return for 2006 with the same spouse, be sure to enter your name and SSNs in the same order as on your 2005 return.” The reason for this statement is because if you switch the taxpayers’ order on the tax return, the IRS computers have trouble tracking it. The IRS computers track tax returns based on the social security number of the “taxpayer.” I have even heard of situations where a taxpayer passed away and when the spouse tried to file as taxpayer (as a widow) in future years, the IRS got confused. From my experience, I would not touch this with a 10-foot pole if a client asked. I get enough unnecessary IRS notices on behalf of clients without tempting them in this area.

So ladies, take note if you are single. When you get married and you file your very first tax return with your new spouse, make sure you get on the top line of that tax return, and maybe you can enjoy being the “taxpayer.” If you don’t take dibs right away, you will never get your chance.

For those of you already married, please don’t take it personally when you go to a tax preparer and they put the man’s name first, if that is how it has been done in past years. Just know we are trying our best to keep the IRS at bay. Maybe in the future the IRS will come up with a better solution. Maybe their computer system will improve to keep track of married filers better. In the meantime, if you are newly married and the order of your names on the tax return has caused the great debate of what constitutes a taxpayer and what constitutes a spouse, just know there is no right or wrong answer. May I suggest flipping a coin? Then stick with your designation for the rest of your marriage.

6 thoughts on “Taxes Have Political Correctness Issues

  1. Interesting. Don’t think this matters to me or my wife, but I know some people I’m sure would throw a fit if they couldn’t get their way.

  2. What an odd post. I’m on my sixth year working for the Big Green tax company, and this has never been a big deal. If they’ve been in before, they’re tracked in OUR system by the “taxpayer’s” SSN, so that’s how we file this year. If they’re new to us I give them the choice, and it’s never particularly drama-filled. Frequently her tax info is more complicated so it makes more sense in their head to make her taxpayer.

    Only if the marriage has serious other issues is it ever anything but a few seconds’ chat and a decision with a grin.

    I’ve never had the IRS complain about the order being reversed.

    This: ‘Unfortunately, try as they might, the IRS is not set up to allow married women to start taking the top line as “taxpayer.

  3. I thought this was very interesting and informative. I for one appreciate the diversity of subjects covered on this website. Something for everyone. That’s why I continue to enjoy it.

  4. Oh – thanks. Glad someone enjoyed.

    You know this topic comes up every so often in the professional crowd and sometimes amusing. Maybe this is more of an issue for our particular type of client because really truly it does come up and creates issues, and is discussed around the water cooler.

    But I just had to say I am all for equality of the law. Just annoyed when the law makes a bad attempt at equality. Simply changing a couple of words on a tax return doesn’t do it for me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *