– A Good Place To Consolidate Credit Card Debt? a good place to consolidate credit card debt?

I received an email regarding my earlier introduction post about and whether it would be a good place to consolidate her credit card debt:

…I have a little under $10,000 in credit card debt where I’m paying about 27% interest on three different cards. The payments are killing me and I’ve been trying to consolidate them at a lower rate, but because my credit rating isn’t good, I can’t get a lower rate card to transfer the balances to.

I saw your post about and I think this would be a good way for me to pay off the high interest credit cards and be able to pay a lower rate. That is what Prosper is for, right? To get loans like this…

While you need to make your own financial decisions based on your circumstances and I can’t tell you what to do, there are some issues that you need to seriously consider.

While Prosper may look like an easy way to consolidate high interest loans, it’s important to run the numbers to see if it will truly help out with your current problem. If it is the current monthly payments that are “killing” you, Prosper may be the last thing you want to do. Why? Because prosper offers a three year loan. Depending on the percentage your credit cards are currently requiring for the minimum payment, getting a loan from Prosper may actually increase your monthly payment even if you get a better interest rate.

Let’s take the following example. If your current credit card requires a 3% minimum payment per month and the credit card balance is $9,500, your minimum monthly payment would be approximately $285. Now if you get the same loan from Prosper at 14% (highly unlikely if you have high risk debt – you would probably have to pay more), your monthly payment would be approximately $325 or $40 per month more than you currently are paying.

Before you look purely at the interest rate, it’s important to make sure that the monthly payments can be met and aren’t going to increase your monthly costs.

This entry was posted in Credit Cards, Debt, Personal Finance. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to – A Good Place To Consolidate Credit Card Debt?

  1. lizriz says:


    I’m wondering what you think of the whole “group” thing on Prosper… it just kinda seems silly, although I could see it potentially working.

  2. pfadvice says:

    I think it depends on how the group is formed and time will start weeding out groups that have been set up merely to generate money – becasue those groups will likely have some defaults making it costly for people in that particular group to borrow.

    Groups that are set up by true group entities I think can lower the risk of default by that “peer pressure” if you know all the people in the group.

    I kind of view it like feedback on ebay. You can’t trust it completely, but looking over the history of the feedback (in this case group) you can get a sense if it is trustworthy or not by the length they have been around and the number of borrowers who paid back the loan in full.

    It will be interesting to see how it all sorts itself out…while proper has a head start, when Zopa USA goes live, it will be interesting to see which one has the better model.

  3. Pingback: Journey To Financial Freedom » Carnival Of Debt Reduction #23

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *